Adrienne Rich breaking misogynistic silence Ethics & Values Featured Content Games male entitlement male hegemony misogynistic silence Montreal Massacre privilege socialized masculinity terrence crowley

Dissecting My Misogynistic Silence – The Good Men Project

Dissecting My Misogynistic Silence - The Good Men Project

Mendacity is completed with phrases, and in addition with silence. – Adrienne Wealthy

Silence has a posh and paradoxical anatomy.

In my very own life, silence has been each an beautiful avenue of equanimity and peace of thoughts in addition to a vicious guardian of my unearned privilege. along with its extra ethereal qualities, silence has served to concretize my sense of entitlement as a person.

Enter Adrienne Wealthy and the fallout from the Montreal Bloodbath bringing an epiphany that eternally modified me. Within the late ‘80s, a friend gave me a copy of Adrienne Rich’s ebook, on Lies, Secrets and techniques, and Silence—each a present and a problem. It definitely proved to be each. Though Wealthy speaks on to ladies in her e-book, she is usually speaking about males and the requirement that ladies lie on our behalf. This mandate for distortion is to be carried out with phrases however typically, and extra insidiously, via silence. What I gleaned from her work is that silence, like all lies, creates fake relationships based mostly on manipulation and characterised by management of others—the hallmark of male socialization.

Previous to discovering Wealthy, I had assumed in a quite unexamined method that my silence within the face of lady-hating behaviors served as a connection to males. Definitely, it prevented battle between us. After studying Wealthy’s work, I used to be pressured to return to grips with the truth that my acutely aware deception not solely spawned energy over relationships with ladies, it additionally, fairly unintentionally, impaired all my relationships with males to whom I used to be additionally mendacity. My silence related me to male superiority and male privilege, to not different males.

Whereas I grappled with the truth that my mendacity via silence was merely a car for management of others, I concurrently tried to carry in thoughts the lengthy-strengthened male tenet that honesty and fact are the essence of manhood. I had assimilated dozens of variations on the supposed truism, ‘A real man is only as good as his word’. What I used to be studying from Wealthy was that male honesty is a type of empirical honesty: the Dow dropped 130 factors at the moment; the Broncos gained 24-10. It’s honesty about information and figures, not emotions and have an effect on. I used to be pressured to acknowledge that we’re baffled by even the prospect of relationships based mostly on genuine affection. As an alternative, our honesty is confined to enterprise, sports activities, and the degradation of girls. Being conscious of our emotional fact isn’t required of us. Fairly the other, a stoic demeanor is the usual—my commonplace.

These have been the concepts I used to be noodling round in my head in December 1989 when Marc Lépine entered an engineering classroom on the École Polytechnique in Montreal with a semi-automated rifle and a searching knife. He instructed the lads to go away the room after which opened hearth on the ladies, killing six, injuring three. He then moved by way of a hall and into the cafeteria persevering with his capturing spree. Earlier than taking his personal life, he killed one other eight ladies and significantly injured 10 others in addition to four males. This occasion has come to be often known as the Montreal Bloodbath. Lépine carried out the bloodbath as a result of, in his phrases, ladies have been taking jobs that rightfully belonged to males. He claimed that feminism equated to the ruination of the material of society and of his life, particularly. He had utilized to the École Polytechnique in 1986, and once more in 1989, however lacked a number of programs required for admission.

The nation and the world have been outraged by the murders.

A number of days later in an try and shake my unhappiness and rage, I attended a memorial service on the native existentialist Church. The format was good. Included into the service was the chance for everybody to precise the depth of their emotions and take consolation in group. As I stood within the queue of 6 or eight individuals ready to talk of my anger and sorrow, the lady on the podium requested the rhetorical query: What would have occurred if the lads (some 50 of them) had refused to go away the room? When challenged by this query, I felt as if a sheet of ice water was thrown throughout my bare physique. How low cost and hole my horror and rage appeared in that second. How typically had I ‘left the room’ both actually or figuratively somewhat than stand shoulder-to-shoulder with ladies? Was my conduct substantively totally different from that of Marc Lépine or just on a unique a part of the continuum of male controls over ladies? At that time, the rostrum was a platform for many who have been really prepared to talk fact to energy. I left the queue and slunk again to my seat the place I contemplated my many previous silent transgressions for the rest of the service.

  • I mirrored on my silence as a younger Military recruit within the midst of a number of dozen others, all of us bewildered by the brand new setting by which we discovered ourselves. There was a palpable awkwardness amongst us as we groped for tactics to attach with one another on this unusual, novel state of affairs. in moments, we discovered our widespread bond: verbally dissecting ladies’s our bodies devoid of their personhood. Whereas I congratulated myself on not becoming a member of in, I nonetheless opted for silence slightly than confrontation for worry of being exiled from the internal circle of male entitlement.
  • I mirrored on my tenure as a furnishings maker, working underneath the tutelage of a German Grasp Craftsman whose bench was suffering from pictures of bare ladies in provocative poses. I stated nothing for worry of jeopardizing a primo apprenticeship and a supply of revenue.
  • I mirrored on my silence on the well being membership when the blokes joked of their want to sexually assault one of many feminine instructors. To intervene would have forged me amongst these to be ridiculed. I used to be conscious about the inevitable alienation I might endure and selected male camaraderie as an alternative.
  • I mirrored on my silence when my brother yelled, screamed, and cursed at his spouse for not obeying his directives. She cowered and silently submitted, as did I, for worry of risking household ties and a connection to my brother’s presumed wealth and energy.

And on and on and on my silences go.

My connection to male energy and privilege, cast by means of my silences, persistently proved extra compelling than the properly-being of girls. Taking the rostrum to talk of my very own rage and unhappiness beneath these circumstances felt disingenuous. Sandwiched between the insights of Adrienne Wealthy and the problem of the lady on the existentialist Church, I knew I had some critical work to do. These seemingly small momentary silences are the stuff that give male hegemony its monumental energy. I didn’t need to proceed a lifetime of lies, however what would substantive change entail for me? Studying the ugly fact about myself introduced ache but in addition a sure aid at figuring out myself higher and being conscious of the extent of my privilege extra deeply. I might name on Adrienne Wealthy and the lady on the existentialist Church for path as I moved ahead. Within the second, change appeared daunting. Nonetheless, I pledged to myself that I might by no means knowingly ‘leave the room’.

In follow, this process has not been as troublesome as I imagined it to be, and, the truth is, I’ve discovered it to be fairly liberating. Breaking silences that oppress others opened me to a different supply of peace and tranquility and put me in contact with my important nature, relatively than my socialized masculinity. As I noticed my burgeoning change course of, I additionally noticed that breaking misogynistic silences brings a peace akin to that of meditative silences. Breaking one’s silence isn’t a lot an affront to different males as a name to excellence; a name for justice; and, a transfer towards the complete expression of our humanity. And so, I want to use this podium to encourage different males to take that very same pledge and expertise that very same peace of thoughts. in my coronary heart of hearts, I really feel fairly positive our collective shift away from these poisonous silences can play a serious position in ending male dominance.

This text is a chapter from the e-book The Anatomy of Silence


What’s Subsequent? Speak with others. Take motion.

We’re pleased with our SOCIAL INTEREST GROUPS—WEEKLY PHONE CALLS to debate, achieve insights, construct communities— and assist remedy a few of the most troublesome challenges the world has right now. Calls are for Members Solely (though you’ll be able to be a part of the primary name at no cost). Not but a member of The Good Men Project? Be a part of under!

RSVP for #StopSexism Calls

 Be a part of the #StopSexism FACEBOOK GROUP right here.


Be a part of The Good Men Project Group

All ranges get to view The Good Men Project website AD-FREE. The $50 Platinum Degree is an ALL-ACCESS PASS—be a part of as many teams and courses as you need for all the yr. The $25 Gold Degree provides you entry to any ONE Social Curiosity Group and ONE Class–and different advantages listed under the shape. Or…for $12, be a part of as a Bronze Member and help our mission, and have a terrific advert-free viewing expertise.

Register New Account

Please word: In case you are already a author/contributor at The Good Men Project, log in right here earlier than registering. (Request new password if wanted).


ANNUAL PLATINUM membership ($50 per yr) consists of:
1. AN ALL ACCESS PASS — Be a part of ANY and ALL of our weekly calls, Social Curiosity Teams, courses, workshops and personal Fb teams. We’ve no less than one group telephone name or on-line class each day of the week.
2. See the web site with no advertisements when logged in!
three. MEMBER commenting badge.
ANNUAL GOLD membership ($25 per yr) consists of all the advantages above — however solely ONE Weekly Social Curiosity Group and ONE class.
ANNUAL BRONZE membership ($12 per yr) is nice in case you are not prepared to hitch the complete dialog however need to help our mission anyway. You’ll nonetheless get a BRONZE commenting badge, and you may pop into any of our weekly Friday Calls with the Writer when you’ve got time. That is for individuals who consider—like we do—that this dialog about males and altering roles and goodness within the 21st century is among the most essential conversations you’ll be able to have immediately.


We’ve got pioneered the most important worldwide dialog about what it means to be a very good man within the 21st century. Your help of our work is inspiring and invaluable.

fbq(‘init’, ‘1803409289699938’);
fbq(‘monitor’, ‘PageView’);
(perform(d, s, id) var js, fjs = d.getElementsByTagName(s)[0]; if (d.getElementById(id)) return; js = d.createElement(s); = id; js.async=true; js.src = ‘’; fjs.parentNode.insertBefore(js, fjs);
(doc, ‘script’, ‘fb-jssdk’));

About the author