advice education Ethics & Values Featured Content Games Inspiration Leadership life Psychology success

Peel the Onion: Why We Answer the Wrong Question

Peel the Onion: Why We Answer the Wrong Question

Questions with out straightforward solutions abound. However we people hate that. Our brains like certainty. Robust, complicated issues with out clear options make us very sad certainly. In these conditions, notably the place public strain exists to discover a quick and clear reply, we’re vulnerable to a kind of mind elf, Daniel Kahneman, writer of Considering, Quick and Sluggish, calls substitution. He writes, “If a satisfactory answer to a hard question is not found quickly, System 1 (our fast-thinking brain) will find a related question that is easier and will answer it.”

Since being positive of one thing is our most popular situation, our brains are likely to do so much to assist us really feel that approach. I wrote about our seek for certainty earlier than, and the way onerous we struggle to protect our model of occasions even once we comprehend it’s mistaken. However, this time we’re speaking about certainty from one other angle. This time, we’re speaking about onions.

The Onion Story
In 1955 an onion farmer and commodities dealer named Vince Kosuga noticed a once-in-a-lifetime alternative. He and his enterprise associate, Sam Siegel, secretly purchased up virtually all of the onions in the U.S. However they didn’t cease at shopping for the onions already harvested, they needed ALL of them–together with the little child onions nonetheless germinating in the floor. They made offers with farmers, a standard follow then and now, to purchase the farmer’s crops at a hard and fast worth someday in the future. That is referred to as a “futures contract.” These two dudes now owned nearly all of the onions in the U.S. And it wasn’t as a result of they beloved the crunchy tang of beer-battered onion rings.
As a result of the males owned 98% of the onions, they used that energy to each drive costs up, as a result of they’d guess on greater costs, after which crash the market, as a result of they’d guess on decrease ones. It obtained so dangerous at one level, the value of a bag crammed with onions was truly lower than the worth of the empty twenty cent bag itself.

Usually, futures contracts assist farmers by permitting them to promote their anticipated crops at a predictable worth. However when Vince and Sam stepped in, the two males made hundreds of thousands, whereas a lot of devastated farmers and others went out of enterprise, some committing suicide. A congressman named Gerald Ford (yep, the future President) determined to behave. He launched the Onion Futures Act banning the sale of futures contracts on onions. The Act was signed into regulation by President Eisenhower in the summer time of 1958.

To this present day, sixty years later, onions are the solely banned commodity in the futures market. The Act meant to stabilize the worth of onions and tackle the considerations of the farmers harm by Vince and Sam’s schemes. However volatility stays even now. The truth is, agricultural economists say the act hurts shoppers and producers, by no means actually assembly its main objective to insulate the market from manipulation and stabilize costs.

However the actual onion market isn’t the solely onion we should always peel again.

My Personal Onion
As soon as, I acquired so mad and scared, as a result of my son had locked himself in his room, that I took the deal with off the door. No extra locked doorways in my home. No extra matches of eight-year-old pique to make his mama fear. Solved that drawback didn’t I?

Oh, wait.

Taking the door deal with off took away a SINGLE drawback. It didn’t ceaselessly remedy the incontrovertible fact that typically youngsters do issues they’ve been warned to not do. No, that’s a way more difficult challenge. One a screwdriver can by no means repair.

You see, I can’t remedy the drawback of a kid’s anger or frustration with one motion. I’ve to spend time and mind effort to determine what went incorrect and why. Then, most significantly, what I have to do subsequent. And I’ve to do that every time one thing occurs. I can’t simply go round eradicating door handles for the remainder of Jackson’s life. I’ve obtained to face the proven fact that being a mother or father requires consolation with uncertainty. It requires a willingness to interact and problem the straightforward, easy solutions that mysteriously seem when the complicated issues simply appear so gosh darned exhausting.

Again to the Different Onions: The Psychology of the Substitution Bias
Regardless of the incontrovertible fact that excessive volatility in the worth of onions continues, the ineffective Act persists. Might it’s that the complicated query, “How do we stop an unscrupulous and greedy few from ruining the opportunity for the many?” is simply too exhausting? And since it’s so onerous, and we would like so badly to have the reply, is that why we create a world of binary all-or-nothing options?

For the document, we changed the door deal with in Jackson’s room. However we purchased one and not using a locking mechanism. In any case, the difficulty was by no means opening and shutting the door. When the time comes, once we’ve obtained an extended monitor document of good-decision making in the face of anger and frustration, the child can have a door that locks. As a result of that’s what that entire factor was about in the first place: belief.

Constructing a relationship constructed on belief with a toddler isn’t straightforward. Neither is it straightforward to simply accept that typically individuals do dangerous issues for egocentric causes. However, they do. And once they do, we should not substitute the straightforward for the exhausting. As a result of once we do this, we lose the belief we so desperately have to construct relationships and communities. Let’s peel again that onion.

We can cease to assume, query our certainty, and proper the wrongs created by the hasty decision-making of the previous. And once we do, we signal a contract with our future selves that serves us all a bit higher in the finish.

Your flip: Are you able to consider points or issues in your personal life or in the world round you the place the substitution bias is in impact?

The Good Males Challenge is totally different from most media corporations. We are a “participatory media company”—which suggests we don’t simply have content material you learn and share and touch upon nevertheless it means we have now a number of methods you possibly can actively be part of the dialog. As you develop into a deeper a part of the dialog—The Dialog No One Else is Having—you’ll study all of the methods we help our Writers’ Group—group FB teams, weekly convention calls, courses in writing, modifying platform constructing and The way to Create Social Change.


Listed here are extra methods to develop into part of The Good Males Venture group:

Request to hitch our personal Fb Group for Writers—it’s like our digital newsroom the place you join with editors and different writers about points and concepts.

Click on right here to grow to be a Premium Member of The Good Males Undertaking Group. Have entry to those advantages:

  1. Get  entry to an unique “Members Only” Group on Fb
  2. Be a part of our Social Curiosity Teams—weekly calls about subjects of curiosity in immediately’s world
  3. View the web site with no advertisements
  4. Get free entry to courses, workshops, and unique occasions
  5. Be invited to an unique weekly “Call with the Publisher” with different Premium Members
  6. Commenting badge.

Are you caught on what to put in writing? Join our Writing Prompts emails, you’ll get concepts instantly from our editors each Monday and Thursday. If you have already got a ultimate draft, then click on under to ship your submit by way of our submission system.

In case you are already working with an editor at GMP, please make sure you identify that individual. In case you are not at present working with a GMP editor, one shall be assigned to you.


Are you a first-time contributor to The Good Males Venture? Submit right here:

submit to Good Men Projectsubmit to Good Men Project


Have you ever contributed earlier than and have a Submittable account? Use our Fast Submit hyperlink right here:


Do you could have beforehand revealed work that you simply want to syndicate on The Good Males Undertaking? Click on right here:

Be a part of our unique weekly “Call with the Publisher” — the place group members are inspired to debate the problems with the week, get story concepts, meet different members and get recognized for his or her concepts? To get the call-in info, both be a part of as a member or wait till you get a publish revealed with us. Listed here are some examples of what we speak about on the calls.

Need to study sensible expertise about find out how to be a greater Author, Editor or Platform Builder? Need to be a Rising Star in Media? Need to discover ways to Create Social Change? We have courses in all of these areas.

When you’re at it, get related with our social media:


Nevertheless, you interact with The Good Males Venture—you possibly can assist lead this dialog about the altering roles of males in the 21st century. Be a part of us!

bottom of post widget GMP community logo (1)bottom of post widget GMP community logo (1)

Do you need to speak about easy methods to have richer, extra aware, and enduring relationships?


We have pioneered the largest worldwide dialog about what it means to be a superb man in the 21st century. Your help of our work is inspiring and invaluable.

The Good Males Undertaking is an affiliate. In case you store by way of THIS LINK, we’ll get a small fee and you may be supporting our Mission whereas nonetheless getting the high quality merchandise you’d have bought, anyway! Thanks on your continued help!


Initially revealed on You Are Superior

Photograph by Tobias Macha on Unsplash

fbq(‘init’, ‘1803409289699938’);
fbq(‘monitor’, ‘PageView’);
(perform(d, s, id) var js, fjs = d.getElementsByTagName(s)[0]; if (d.getElementById(id)) return; js = d.createElement(s); = id; js.async=true; js.src = ‘’; fjs.parentNode.insertBefore(js, fjs);
(doc, ‘script’, ‘facebook-jssdk’));

About the author